The Montreal Canadiens’ decision to draft David Reinbacher fifth overall in 2023 has sparked significant debate among fans and analysts alike, especially when compared to the allure of Matvei Michkov. As the dust settles on the draft, new insights reveal that Reinbacher was not merely a safe pick but a coveted prospect that several other teams had their sights set on.

In a recent analysis by TVA Sports, it was disclosed that the Arizona Coyotes, Philadelphia Flyers, Washington Capitals, and Nashville Predators all had plans to select Reinbacher, demonstrating the high regard in which he was held. The Coyotes, who picked sixth, reportedly had Reinbacher as their top choice, while the Capitals, who selected Ryan Leonard eighth, also expressed strong interest in the Swiss defenseman. Notably, the Predators, drafting fifteenth, were rumored to have been willing to trade up for Reinbacher, further underscoring his value across the league.

Despite the initial skepticism from some Canadiens fans regarding the decision to pass on Michkov, who is known for his offensive prowess, Reinbacher’s profile as a solid right-handed defenseman remains compelling. His size, mobility, and two-way capabilities draw comparisons to elite players like Moritz Seider. However, Reinbacher’s progress has been hindered by injuries, limiting his appearances in the AHL last season.

The Canadiens’ management, including head coach Martin St. Louis, demonstrated confidence in Reinbacher, praising his potential and unanimously supporting the selection. This endorsement from the coaching staff suggests that Reinbacher’s s𝓀𝒾𝓁𝓁s align with the team’s vision for the future.

As the Canadiens look ahead, the narrative surrounding Reinbacher is shifting. While his immediate contributions may be uncertain due to health concerns, the consensus among NHL insiders is that he possesses the tools for a successful career. Fans must remain patient, as the anticipation builds for Reinbacher’s eventual emergence in the NHL. The question remains: did the Canadiens make the right choice? With multiple teams eyeing Reinbacher, the answer may lie in his future performance on the ice.